The Rising Tide of Uninsured Americans and the Looming Threat of ACA Subsidies Ending in 2026

The latest figures from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) are sounding alarms across the healthcare landscape. More than 8% of Americans were uninsured during the first months of 2024, a significant uptick from the record-low uninsured rates observed in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic. According to the CDC’s National Health Interview Survey, an estimated 27.1 million Americans of all ages lacked health insurance by March 2024. This marks an increase of 3.4 million uninsured individuals compared to the same period in 2023, when the uninsured rate was around 7.7%.

A Concerning Trend

This preliminary data points to a concerning trend in uninsured rates, with projections indicating a possible return to pre-pandemic levels by 2026. The rise in uninsured Americans follows years of historically low rates, which the Biden administration had touted as a success. During 2023, the proportion of uninsured people fell below 8% for four consecutive quarters.

Experts and officials credit these record-low rates to several pandemic-era changes in health insurance policies. Before 2020, the nation’s uninsured rate had peaked at over 10%. One significant factor in reducing the uninsured rate was the pause on states verifying Medicaid eligibility during the pandemic, which effectively suspended the “churn” that often results in eligible enrollees losing coverage. However, this process—known as Medicaid “unwinding”—is expected to conclude in most states by this month, potentially driving up the number of uninsured individuals.

The Future of ACA Subsidies

The Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) estimated in June that the number of Americans covered by health insurance would likely revert to pre-pandemic levels by 2026. This projection is based on anticipated declines in Medicaid enrollment and the expiration of temporary subsidies. The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) has also forecasted worsening uninsured rates in the coming years. In addition to the end of pandemic-era policies, the CBO points to a surge in immigration as another factor likely to increase uninsured rates.

A critical component at risk is the Affordable Care Act (ACA) marketplace health insurance exchange, which relies heavily on federal subsidies. These enhanced subsidies, enacted during the COVID-19 pandemic and extended through the federal Inflation Reduction Act, are scheduled to end in 2026 unless renewed by Congress. The end of these subsidies could significantly impact the affordability of health insurance for millions of Americans.

Policy Implications of Not Extending ACA Subsidies

The potential cessation of ACA subsidies carries profound implications for American healthcare:

1. Loss of Access to Affordable Health Insurance:

Millions of Americans could lose access to affordable health insurance, leading to a significant rise in the uninsured population. This would disproportionately affect those with lower incomes, who rely heavily on these subsidies to afford coverage.

2. Increased Financial Burden:

Individuals and families may find the financial burden of health insurance premiums unsustainable without subsidies. This could force many to either pay exorbitant premiums or forego insurance altogether, leaving them vulnerable in times of medical need.

3. Strain on the Healthcare System:

A larger uninsured population could result in more uncompensated care, shifting costs onto healthcare providers and insured individuals through higher premiums. This could strain hospitals and clinics, potentially reducing the quality of care.

4. Compromised Public Health Initiatives:

With more individuals uninsured, public health and wellness initiatives may suffer. Preventive care and early diagnosis could decline, leading to more severe health conditions and higher long-term healthcare costs.

5. Worsening Health Disparities:

The cessation of ACA subsidies could exacerbate existing health disparities, disproportionately affecting communities of color and low-income individuals. This would widen the gap in access to healthcare services, further entrenching inequalities in the healthcare system.

Policy Alternatives and the Path Forward

If ACA subsidies are not extended, policymakers will need to explore alternative strategies to ensure affordable healthcare access for all. Potential revisions or additions to current healthcare policy could include:

• State-Based Subsidies:

States could introduce their own subsidy programs to help residents afford health insurance, similar to efforts seen in Massachusetts and California.

• Public Health Insurance Options:

Introducing public health insurance options or expanding existing ones, such as Medicaid, could provide a safety net for those who lose access to ACA subsidies.

• Increased Investment in Preventive Care:

Investing in preventive care initiatives could reduce long-term health costs by catching diseases early and improving overall public health.

• Enhanced Support for Community Health Centers:

Bolstering support for community health centers could ensure that underserved populations continue to receive essential care, even if they are uninsured.

The rising uninsured rates in the first quarter of 2024 signal a troubling trend that could worsen if the ACA subsidies end in 2026. With 27.1 million Americans uninsured and projections indicating a potential return to pre-pandemic levels, urgent action is needed to ensure that healthcare remains accessible and affordable for all. Policymakers must consider extending ACA subsidies or implementing alternative strategies to prevent a healthcare crisis.

Call to Action:

Stay updated on the latest healthcare policy developments and join the conversation. Sign up for our newsletter to receive expert insights and actionable advice on navigating the changing landscape of American healthcare.